Justin Hall’s documentary “Overshare” describes his early experiences with blogging on the internet. His detailed and unfiltered posts left little to the imagination about his life. He didn’t consider the negative effects of putting his whole life on the internet, and this later caused problems in his professional and social life.
Merton’s term “unintended consequences” is a perfect way to represent what happened. Hall was simply having fun saying whatever he wanted on his blog, including people’s names and adding some vulgar images. Soon his family and friends took notice that their private stories were now available for anyone to read. Hall talks about becoming alienated by his loved ones because they feared anything they said would end up on his blog. Eventually he began to leave off or change people’s names once he saw the problems he was causing.
Kranzberg’s first law of technology is that “Technology is neither good nor bad; nor is it neutral.” I think this can be applied to Hall’s story because the technology itself had nothing to do with the positive or negative outcomes of his blog. It had everything to do with his choices of what to put on the website.
Many people associate current problems with society with different technological devices, such as phones in school causing kids to lose focus in class, but I disagree with this mentality. As I stated earlier, the unintended consequences of upsetting his family weren’t caused by his website, they were caused by what he was putting on the website.
However, the website did make the stories available to many more people. So, in some ways, the technology was not completely blameless, as it made the information spread much easier and quicker. But at the same time, the rapid spread of information can be a very positive thing too, like if there is a dangerous situation that people need to be made aware of.
Leave a Reply